A Pentatonix Christmas (Deluxe) is a cappella holiday comfort that lands harder on the second listen. What sounded like fluff on casual play reveals itself as genuinely inventive vocal engineering and arrangement—five singers doing what a full orchestra used to do, and mostly pulling it off. Perfect for the late-night listening when you're actually paying attention.
You probably haven’t really listened to this one since early December, when it was the soundtrack to wrapping presents or cooking dinner and half your attention was somewhere else. That’s the curse of a Christmas album—even a good one gets relegated to background utility, filed away the moment New Year’s passes. But A Pentatonix Christmas deserves a proper hearing on a quiet night, which is the only way to understand what they actually built here.
Start with “Hallelujah.” Not the Leonard Cohen one everyone knows—Pentatonix arranges it for pure vocal texture, and watching how they layer five human voices into what sounds like synth pads and string sections is genuinely the work of a serious ear. Kevin Olusola didn’t just throw beatbox under it; he composed a rhythm section that sits in the pocket tight enough to make a session drummer jealous. That’s the revelation hiding in this album: it’s not trying to be a string orchestra or a gospel choir. It’s five mouths trying to become an instrument that never existed before.
The production choices matter more here than you probably noticed on first spin. Ben Folds produces the deluxe version, and his influence shows most clearly in the arrangements—there’s space between the voices, room for air. “Mary, Did You Know?” could have been drowned in harmonies; instead, they let it breathe. The lead vocal sits high and exposed, supported but not buried. That’s restraint, and it’s rarer than it should be.
What’s Actually Happening
Listen to how they handle “The Christmas Song (Chestnuts Roasting on an Open Fire).” This is a mid-century standard that’s been sung to death, but Pentatonix reaches back to something almost doo-wop in structure—stacked vocals creating texture, call-and-response, the bass line (here it’s Eder Lara’s voice, shaped into something that moves like a string bass) holding the whole thing together. It’s not a parody. It’s a translation.
The deluxe edition was worth holding onto precisely because the bonus tracks aren’t afterthoughts. “Carol of the Bells” is where they let loose—genuinely audacious, with layering that spins almost psychedelic by the bridge. This is where you hear what separates competent a cappella from something that actually justifies the format.
“Joy to the World” sits at the other end of the spectrum—minimal, almost hymnal, the kind of arrangement that could only work if everyone involved understood exactly what a cappella needs to breathe. There’s no padding. No showing off. Just five people singing something true.
The reason to put this back on isn’t nostalgia or obligation. It’s that this is what happens when a group stops trying to prove a cappella belongs in the room and just makes it work. No apologies. No imitation. Ben Folds understood that—he didn’t hire an orchestra, and he didn’t let Pentatonix overdub themselves into submission. He let them be what they are: the instrument itself.
🎵 Key Takeaways
- Pentatonix layers five voices into synthesizer-like textures on Hallelujah arrangement.
- Kevin Olusola's beatbox composes tight rhythm sections rivaling professional session drummers.
- Ben Folds production prioritizes space and air between vocal layers throughout.
- Christmas Song uses doo-wop structure with bass voice moving like string bass.
- Album reveals serious instrumental composition hidden beneath holiday album surface utility.
Why is this worth serious listening and not just background music?
Because the arrangement work here is genuinely sophisticated. These aren't ornamental harmonies layered on top of a melody—Pentatonix is using five human voices as the complete instrument, which means every choice about texture, balance, and space matters. Ben Folds understood that and produced accordingly. Listen to what Kevin Olusola's beatbox is actually doing rhythmically, or how the bass voices sit in the mix—it's all composed.
Is the deluxe version actually better than the standard?
Yes, because Ben Folds' production philosophy is audible in every track. The standard edition has merit, but the deluxe version sounds like someone who respected the group's limitations and turned them into strengths. There's more air in the mixes, the vocals sit better relative to each other, and the arrangements breathe. If you're putting this on now, make sure you're listening to the right version.
Which tracks should I focus on for understanding what makes this work?
'Hallelujah' shows restraint and production discipline. 'Carol of the Bells' shows what happens when they let loose. 'The Christmas Song' is where you hear the influence of older vocal harmony groups—doo-wop DNA, basically. Listen to those three back-to-back and you'll understand the range.
More from Pentatonix