When five teenagers from Arlington, Texas decided to release a Christmas album in 2013, nobody needed to hear another one. The market was overflowing with seasonal sentimentality and safe covers. Pentatonix had just won The Sing Off the year before and had momentum, sure, but a cappella Christmas records had a particular reputation: either aggressively wholesome or too clever for their own good.
What they made instead sits somewhere in between, which is exactly where it needed to.
The record opens with “Hark! The Herald Angels Sing,” and if you’re braced for breathy, overly precious vocal layering, the first thirty seconds will reset your expectations. The arrangement—credited to producer Kevin Kiley and Pentatonix themselves—sits in actual space. The bass line (Scott Hoying and Mitch Grassi handling most of the lead work across the record) doesn’t apologize for being a bass line. There’s percussion woven in, subtle but there, courtesy of beatboxer Kevin Olusola. It doesn’t sound like five people trapped in a booth. It sounds like a band.
The Craft of Restraint
The decision to bring in multiple producers—Kiley alongside Ben Folds for a few tracks—means the album never settles into a single sonic palette. “White Christmas” gets an almost retro, close-harmony treatment that recalls ‘40s vocal groups, but with modern compression and clarity that those records never had. The tuning is immaculate. No one’s chasing perfection into the uncanny valley; they’re just good enough that you stop thinking about the technical feat and start listening to the song.
Kirstin Maldonado’s voice, often pushed to the front on their uptempo numbers, gets space to breathe on “O Come All Ye Faithful” in ways that suggest the team understood that a cappella Christmas music lives or dies on whether you believe the singers actually believe in what they’re singing.
The album’s real test comes in the middle section, where lesser producers would have leaned into arrangement as compensation for the lack of instruments. Here, they don’t. “Joy to the World” is straightforward four-part harmony, nearly hymnal, because sometimes the song doesn’t need rescuing. The choice feels mature for a group this young.
What Age Had to Do With It
This was 2013—Pentatonix still had the energy of young artists with something to prove but not yet the jadedness of people who’ve been asked to do the same thing a hundred times. Olusola’s beatboxing, which could easily overwhelm a cappella arrangements in lesser hands, is mixed like a drummer who knows when not to play. When he does step into a groove on “Jingle Bells,” it lands because he’s earned the space by being absent elsewhere.
The closing track, an original called “Christmas in Hollis,” feels like the moment they exhale. It’s funky, surprisingly so, with enough vocal personality that you hear each member as distinct. It suggests they were thinking beyond “execute the Christmas album” and toward “make people remember this one.”
By 2024 standards, this record sounds almost quaint—the production is clean but not overprocessed, the arrangements ambitious but not precious. That was exactly right for the moment. It sold over a million copies, made Pentatonix visible to people who never watched The Sing Off, and proved that there was still room in Christmas music for something that respected both the tradition and the listener’s patience.
It’s not a perfect record. There are moments where the close harmony gets a little too close, where the sweetness edges into saccharine. But it’s close enough that you want to return to it, and that’s the only thing a Christmas album ever really needs to be.
🎵 Key Takeaways
- Pentatonix released Christmas album when market was oversaturated with seasonal records.
- Bass line sits in actual space instead of apologizing for existing.
- Beatboxer Kevin Olusola adds subtle percussion making five people sound like band.
- Multiple producers prevented album from settling into single sonic palette throughout.
- Tuning immaculate enough that listeners stop noticing technical feat and hear song.
- Kristin Maldonado's voice given space suggesting team understood belief matters most.
Why does Pentatonix's Christmas album sound like a band instead of five people in a booth?
Producer Kevin Kiley and the group itself prioritized actual space and arrangement restraint—the bass line doesn't apologize for existing, beatboxer Kevin Olusola's percussion is woven in subtly, and they resisted the trap of layering vocals into an overcrowded mix. The production choices treat it as an ensemble with distinct roles rather than a stack of overdubs.
Who produced That's Christmas to Me and why does it matter?
Kevin Kiley handled most of the record with Ben Folds contributing to a few tracks, which prevented the album from settling into a single sonic palette and kept arrangements from becoming formulaic. Having multiple producers meant different philosophical approaches to restraint versus arrangement ambition across the tracklist.
How does Pentatonix handle the beatboxing on a Christmas album without it becoming gimmicky?
Kevin Olusola's beatboxing is mixed like a drummer who knows when not to play—it's absent on most tracks, which earns it the space to actually land when it does appear. On 'Jingle Bells,' the groove feels earned rather than imposed because he's spent the rest of the album establishing restraint.
What made Pentatonix's 2013 Christmas record commercially successful in an oversaturated market?
It respected both the tradition of Christmas music and the listener's patience by avoiding aggressive wholesomeness or overcleverness, instead sitting in the practical middle ground. The record sold over a million copies and introduced Pentatonix to audiences beyond The Sing Off's viewer base.
More from Pentatonix